Selected cases:
Panel on Takeovers and Mergers v King 2018 SC 459
Acted for the Panel, in first enforcement proceedings in the UK under section 955 of the Companies Act 2006. The proceedings sought an order for Mr King to make a mandatory offer under the Takeover Code, to acquire all the issued ordinary shares of Rangers International Football Club plc.
SSE Generation Ltd v Hochtief Solutions [2016] CSOH 177
A dispute arising out of the collapse of a hydropower tunnel built by Hochtief for SSE, and involving NEC2 contract interpretation. One of the longest evidential hearings in the Scottish courts in recent years, with the first instance factual inquiry taking two court terms to complete. Acted for SSE at first instance, as part of the quantum team (the aspect on which SSE was successful at first instance and which was not appealed).
Inveresk plc v Tullis Russell Papermakers Ltd 2010 SC (UKSC) 106
In this and the connected case between the same parties, Almira together with senior counsel acted for Tullis Russell, in successfully claiming at the Supreme Court level that the payment of deferred consideration under an asset purchase agreement was not as yet due and that, in any event, Tullis had right to retain any sums due pending the resolution of their claim for damages against Inveresk. A complex factual hearing on the damages claim concluded after the Supreme Court case and Tullis were awarded significant damages against Inveresk.
Martin v Most 2010 SC (UKSC) 40
This was the first judgement by the Supreme Court dealing with the challenge to the extent of legislative competence of the Scottish Parliament on grounds other than compliance with the European Convention on Human Rights. The judgment contains important considerations of section 29 of the Scotland Act, which lies at the heart of the division between matters reserved for the UK Parliament and matters within the powers of the devolved legislature.
Farstad Supply AS v Enviroco Ltd 2010 SC (UKSC) 87
The case concerned a claim for damages and repair costs in relation to damage caused by a fire on board an oil supply vessel. The main issue in the case was whether the terms of a contract between the pursuers and the third party resulted in the defenders being unable to claim relief from the third party.
Scottish Lion Insurance Co Ltd v First Goodrich Corp 2010 SC 349
Acted for Scottish Lion, a solvent insurance company, in their successful appeal relating to a scheme of arrangement under s. 899 of the Companies Act 2006. The court held that the existence of an adverse situation facing both the company and its creditors might be a factor in favour of granting sanction of the scheme, but was not a precondition thereto, whether the company was solvent or otherwise. The fact that insured with long tail policies were asked to accept current estimated values in lieu of their contingent claims was not so overwhelming a factor against the granting of sanction that Scottish Lion could be denied the opportunity of establishing the positive benefits of the scheme and robustness of its valuation procedures.
Anderson v Dickens 2009 SCLR 609
Successful challenge of two transactions as 'unfair preferences' on behalf of the liquidator against the company's director and sole shareholder.
Arrow Generics Ltd, Petitioners 2008 SC 518
In this challenge to a European patent, acted for Akzo Nobel in successfully overturning on appeal the first instance finding that the patent lacked novelty, while also successfully defending the first instance finding that the patent was not obvious.
Calor Gas Ltd v Express Fuels (Scotland) Ltd 2008 SLT 123
Acted for Express Fuels, who were successful in defending an action for damages for breach of contracts by showing that the relevant contracts were void due to breach of European competition law.
See also:
Strathedin Properties Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2018] UKFTT 293 (TC)
Joint Administrators of Granite City Assets Ltd, Petitioners [2018] CSOH 55
Biffa Waste Services Ltd v Patersons of Greenoakhill Ltd [2015] CSOH 137
West of Scotland Colleges Partnership v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2014] UKFTT 622 (TC)
Caithness Creels Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2014]UKUT 97 (TCC)
G1 Venues Ltd, Petitioners [2013] CSOH 202
Butlers Ship Stores Ltd v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2014] STC 732
Graeme M Fraser & Co v Royal Bank of Scotland plc [2013] CSIH 56
Sane Investments Ltd v Astrazeneca UK Ltd [2013] CSOH 81
Simpson & Marwick v Revenue and Customs Commissioners [2013] STC 2275
Farstad Supply AS v Enviroco Ltd 2013 SC 302 (IH), 2012 SLT 348 (OH)
Patersons of Greenoakhill Ltd v Biffa Waste ServicesLtd 2013 SLT 729
Joint Administrators of Prestonpans (Trading) Ltd, Petitioners 2013 SLT 138
Official Liquidator of Weir Construction (Contracts) Ltd, Noter 2012 SLT 1098
Kivuwatt Ltd v Dane Associates Ltd [2012] CSIH 27 (IH), [2011] CSOH 118 (OH)
Scottish Lion Insurance Co Ltd, Petitioner [2012] CSOH 5
Tullis Russell Papermakers Ltd v Inveresk Ltd [2010] CSOH 148
Romano v Standard Commercial Property Securities Ltd 2008 SLT 859
Calor Gas Ltd v Express Fuels (Scotland) Ltd 2008 SLT 123
Potter v Scottish Prison Service 2007 SLT 1019
Allen v MacTaggart 2007 SC 482
Drimsynie Estate Ltd v Ramsay 2006 SLT 528
Caterleisure Ltd v Glasgow Prestwick International Airport Ltd 2006 SC 602